The Best Homemade Sweet Cherry Pie Recipe | Sweet Pea's Kitchen (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read the disclosure policy.

Every bite of this sweet cherry pie is filled with plump, juicy cherries, and a flaky vodka pie crust. This easy cherry pie is pure heaven as soon as the sweetness hits your tongue. I’ve always been a fan of pies, and it’s one of my favorite things to bake too.

Scroll to bottom for printable recipe card.

The Best Homemade Sweet Cherry Pie Recipe

Whenever you make the best cherry pie recipe, you’ll find that it goes really fast. So if you want to have leftovers or feed a crowd, I recommend making multiple pies because it will get gobbled up…fast! I prefer to use fresh cherries, and it makes the texture and pie filling out of this world. Make this fresh cherry pie for picnics, pool parties, or even holidays! Homemade cherry pie also makes a lovely gift for friends, neighbors, and co-workers.

Sweet Cherry Pie Ingredients

The best thing about this easy cherry pie is that you can use fresh or frozen cherries. I almost always use fresh, but frozen is an excellent option if they aren’t in season. Take a peek at these ingredients for this fresh cherry pie.

For the Pie Crust

• All-purpose flour – You’ll need the flour for the pie crust and a little bit for dusting the counter to roll it out on.
• Salt – Salt is always an essential ingredient when baking. You don’t need a ton, just a little bit.
• Sugar – Give the crust a sweetness with some sugar. This is the best cherry pie recipe because of all the small details that come together.
• Unsalted butter – Always use cold butter when making pie crust. It makes a huge difference in how this fresh cherry pie will turn out.
• Vegetable shortening -To allow the pie to cook properly and the crust to be flaky and delicious shortening is an asset.
• Vodka – Use really chilled vodka for this yummy homemade cherry pie. Trust me; this is a beautiful addition to the crust.
• Water – Adding some water will give the crust that texture we all crave when eating a piece of the pie.

For the Cherry Filling

• Red plums – You may not realize it, but adding red plums to this sweet cherry pie is amazing. It adds another sweetness factor, and it’s so scrumptious.
• Sweet cherries – It’s okay to use fresh or frozen cherries. Entirely up to you, and it will turn out drool-worthy no matter which way you go.
• Sugar – Give your homemade cherry pie filling a little more sugary sweetness. Yum!
• Salt – A dash of salt helps bring out the flavors of the cherries and plums.
• Lemon – Whenever possible, use freshly squeezed lemon juice. It’s a lovely asset to this best cherry pie recipe.
• Bourbon – Enjoy a slice or two of this boozy cherry pie, and you’ll be so glad you made it!
• Instant tapioca – Make sure that the tapioca is ground up really well.
• Ground cinnamon – You can never go wrong with adding a little cinnamon to a homemade pie.
• Unsalted butter – If you end up using salted butter, just make sure not to put the salt in the filling.
• Egg – The egg wash gives the pie that gorgeous golden brown color we all love.

How To Make Cherry Pie

I’m so excited to share with you how to make a flavorful cherry pie from scratch. This fresh cherry pie is unlike anything I’ve tried before. Get ready to start baking the best cherry pie recipe ever.

First Step: Using a food processor with a metal blade, add 1 1/2 cups of flour, salt, and sugar until it’s combined. Use 1-second pulses until mixed. Put the butter and shortening in the food processor and work until the dough clumps. This usually takes about 15 seconds and should closely resemble cottage cheese curds, and none of the flour should be uncoated. Scrape the bowl as needed. Mix in the remaining flour and pulse. Place the dough mixture in a medium-sized bowl.

Second Step: Next, you’ll need to drizzle the vodka and water over the pie dough mixture. Using a rubber spatula, mix in a folding motion and press down until the dough is tacky and sticks together.

NOTE: Using vodka is important to give the crust the perfect texture. Don’t skip this step, or the crust won’t turn out correctly. You can use any 80 proof liquor if you don’t have vodka on hand.

Third Step: Divide the pie dough into two dough balls and flatten them into 4-inch disks. Use plastic wrap to wrap each of the dough balls and refrigerate for 45 minutes or all the way up to 2 days.

Fourth Step: Take the first disk out of the fridge and roll it out onto a floured surface. Roll until its a 12-inch circle and around 1/8 inch thick. Pick the dough up with the rolling pin by lightly rolling it around the rolling pin. Unroll the dough onto the pie plate and leave around 1-inch overhang. Press the dough gently into the pie pan and refrigerate for around 40 minutes.

Fifth Step: Place the oven rack to the bottom position and place a baking sheet on the oven rack — Preheat the oven to 400 degrees.

Sixth Step: Using a food processor, add the plums and 1 cup of cherries and mix until smooth. Scrape down the sides as needed. Strain the cherry puree through a fine-mesh strainer and place it in a large bowl. Try to get all the liquid out of any solid pieces then discard them. In the bowl, add the remaining cherries, sugar, salt, lemon juice, bourbon, tapioca, and cinnamon to the cherry puree mixture and let stand for 15 minutes.

Note: If you are using frozen fruit, it’s important to measure it frozen, but let it thaw before making the filling. Otherwise, you may have partially cooked fruit, and the tapioca won’t be dissolved properly.

Seventh Step: Pour the cherry mixture into the pan with the pie dough. Add pieces of butter all over the fruit. Then roll out the second pie crust dough ball onto the floured surface until it’s 12-inches in diameter and 1/8 inch thick. Using a pastry wheel, cut the dough into 12 strips that are each 3/4 inch wide. Place 6 of the strips horizontally across the pie. Weave in the other six vertical strips. Trim the edges of the overhang pie crust and flute them with your thumb and forefinger. You can also use a fork to seal the edges. Use the egg wash on the edges and top of the pie then freeze for 20 minutes.

Eighth Step: Add the pie to the preheated baking sheet and bake for 30 minutes. After 30 minutes, lower the temperature to 350 degrees and continue baking until the juices are bubbling. The crust should be a golden brown, which usually takes around 30-40 more minutes.

Ninth Step: Place the pie to a wire rack and let it cool for 2-3 hours until the juice is thick. Cut into pieces and serve. Enjoy!

How Do You Store This Sweet Cherry Pie?

It’s best to store the sweet cherry pie in the refrigerator after it’s cooled down long enough. It would last 1-2 days on the counter but will last 3-4 days in the fridge. Plus, this homemade cherry pie tastes amazing when it’s cold too! You can also toss it in the microwave to warm it up if you prefer it hot.

Just make sure that the fresh cherry pie is wrapped tightly in plastic wrap or aluminum foil and kept in an airtight storage container. Never set it next to strong-smelling food in the fridge, or it may take on those flavors.

Can You Freeze This Homemade Cherry Pie?

Yes, you can freeze this sweet cherry pie. Just wrap it up and place it in the freezer for 1-2 months, and you can enjoy the best cherry pie recipe at a later time! It’s perfect for meal planning or doubling the recipe to have some later too.

Can’t get enough of this yummy homemade cherry pie? You should sink your teeth into some of my other pie inspired recipes:

• Easy Key Lime Pie Recipe – The flavor of this key lime pie is mind-blowing! You’ll want a second piece because it’s just so good.
• No-Bake Orange Creamsicle Pie – This is one of the easiest pie recipes ever! You will be amazed by how good it is too.
• Cinnamon Toast Crunch Pudding Pie – If you love no-bake pies, add this one to your list. Just thinking about this pie makes me hungry. So good!
• Easy Millionaire Pie – You’ll never go wrong with serving this gorgeous and flavorful pie. Everyone will love it.

Now, remember to save this recipe on Pinterest for later 🙂

Make sure you check my best recipes below:

Truffle Peanut Butter Brownies – This 3 layer brownie has peanut butter filling and then it is topped with chocolate ganache. Rich, creamy and delicious, you have to try these ones of a kind brownies.

Crown Royal Cherry Brownies Balls – Do you love chocolate covered cherries? Looking for a recipe for cherry brownies? This is the best chocolate truffles that you will ever taste.

Black Forest Brownies Recipe – These black forest brownies will knock the socks off of any chocolate lover! Rich and decadent, these delicious cherry brownies from scratch are much easier to make than their delightful flavor would have you assume!

Cherry Cheesecake Brownies – What’s a better dessert – cheesecake or brownies? With these easy Cherry Cheesecake Brownies, you don’t have to choose! Cherry brownies are a tasty twist on a classic brownie.

Red Velvet Brownies with White Chocolate Buttercream Frosting – Make these homemade red velvet brownies with delicious white chocolate buttercream frosting. Rich, chewy chocolate fudge brownies with an amazing taste.